Mortgage Insurance Protects the Lender, and You Pay for It

Mortgage insurance pays your lender if you stop paying. You usually owe it when you put down less than 20%, as PMI on a conventional loan or MIP on an FHA loan. PMI can end at 80% or 78% of your original value. FHA MIP often lasts as long as the loan.

Tech Talk News Editorial9 min read
ShareXLinkedInRedditEmail
Mortgage Insurance Protects the Lender, and You Pay for It

Key takeaways

  • Mortgage insurance protects the lender, not the borrower, if the borrower stops paying, and it is usually required on a conventional loan when the down payment is under 20%.
  • Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac must obtain credit enhancement, most often mortgage insurance, on any loan above 80% of the home value, so the 20% down payment line is a rule for the buyer of your loan.
  • Under the Homeowners Protection Act, a borrower with good payment history can ask the servicer to cancel private mortgage insurance (PMI) at 80% of the original value, and PMI must end automatically at 78% if the borrower is current.
  • FHA charges an upfront premium of 1.75% and an annual premium of 0.55% for a 3.5%-down 30-year loan of $726,200 or less, and that annual premium lasts the full loan term, or 11 years if the borrower put down 10% or more.
  • Private mortgage insurance on a 3.5%-down conventional loan ran from 0.46% to 1.50% of the loan a year in a June 2023 Urban Institute rate-card comparison, depending on credit score, while FHA charged a flat 0.55%.

Mortgage insurance is a policy that pays your lender if you stop making your mortgage payments, and you are the one who pays the premium. You usually owe it when you put down less than 20% of the price.

On a conventional loan it is called private mortgage insurance, or PMI; on a loan insured by the Federal Housing Administration (FHA, the government mortgage insurer) it is called the mortgage insurance premium, or MIP.[1]

PMI can come off your bill once you build enough equity. FHA MIP often stays for the life of the loan. That one difference moves more money than any rate quote you will see, and it is the reason this article exists.

20%
Down payment that usually avoids PMI
80% / 78%
Request / automatic PMI cancellation
1.75%
FHA upfront premium
0.55%
FHA annual premium at 3.5% down

What mortgage insurance is, and who it protects

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB, the federal consumer finance regulator) puts it in one line: PMI protects the lender, not you, if you stop making payments on your loan. If you fall behind you can still lose the home to foreclosure.[1] You are buying a policy whose only beneficiary is the bank.

So why does the lender make you pay for it?

The 20% line comes from the companies that buy your loan. Under their charters, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac must obtain credit enhancement when a loan's balance exceeds 80% of the property's value, and the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA, their regulator) says mortgage insurance is the most commonly used form of it.

The insurance covers the first losses on loans above 80% loan-to-value (LTV, the loan balance divided by the home's value).[5]

I find that clarifying. Twenty percent isn't a measure of whether you can afford the house. It is the threshold at which the buyer of your loan stops wanting to absorb the first loss, and you pay the premium for crossing it.

PMI vs FHA MIP, side by side

PMI is arranged by your lender and provided by private insurers. You can pay it monthly, as a one-time premium at closing, or as a combination of both, and the CFPB notes that you might not get an upfront premium back if you move or refinance.[1] FHA MIP is set by the government, and almost every FHA borrower pays it.

PMI compared with FHA MIP
Conventional PMIFHA MIP
Who provides itPrivate insurers, through your lenderFHA
Upfront costOptional, monthly or combined1.75% of the base loan, usually financed
Annual cost0.46% to 1.50% at 3.5% down (2023 rates), by credit score0.55% at 3.5% down, same for every credit score
Priced onCredit score and down paymentLoan size, term and down payment
How it endsRequest at 80%, automatic at 78%, final at the loan's midpoint11 years if you put down 10% or more, otherwise the full loan term

The FHA numbers come from HUD's Mortgagee Letter 2023-05, which cut annual premiums by 30 basis points. For a base loan of $726,200 or less with a term over 15 years, the annual rate is 0.50% when the LTV is 90% or below and the premium ends after 11 years.

Between 90% and 95% it is 0.50% for the full term. Above 95%, which is where a 3.5% down payment lands, it is 0.55% for the full term. The upfront premium is 1.75% of the base loan on every mortgage.[6]

What it costs, with real numbers

Take a $400,000 home with 3.5% down. The base loan is $386,000. FHA adds an upfront premium of $6,755 (1.75%), usually rolled into the loan, and then 0.55% a year, about $2,123 a year or $177 a month.

Private PMI on the same loan is a range, because insurers price it on your credit score. The Urban Institute (a Washington research group) compared June 2023 rate cards for a 3.5%-down conventional loan and found PMI ran from 1.50% a year for the weakest credit scores down to 0.46% for the strongest.

On $386,000 that is about $5,790 a year ($483 a month) at the top and $1,776 a year ($148 a month) at the bottom.[7] Those are 2023 quotes. The shape holds, the exact cents don't.

Conventional PMI

FHA annual MIP

  1. Credit score 639 or lower
    1.50%
    0.55%
  2. Credit score 680 to 699
    0.98%
    0.55%
  3. Credit score 720 to 739
    0.70%
    0.55%
  4. Credit score 780 or higher
    0.46%
    0.55%
Annual premium as a percent of the loan at 96.5% LTV (3.5% down), June 2023 rate cards, before loan-level price adjustments. Source: Urban Institute.

The chart is why FHA wins for weaker credit and PMI wins for strong credit. FHA doesn't care about your score for the premium, and PMI cares a lot.

Urban's fuller comparison, which adds the loan-level price adjustments that Fannie and Freddie charge, found FHA cheaper at 3.5% down for every borrower except those above a 760 score.[7] That is a June 2023 snapshot, so run it again with live quotes.

Why this matters

A loan without PMI usually carries a higher interest rate, so “no PMI” isn't automatically cheaper. The CFPB says which option costs less depends on how long you plan to keep the home.[1]

How to get rid of PMI

This is where conventional loans pull ahead. The Homeowners Protection Act (HPA, the federal law covering private mortgage insurance on single-family homes closed on or after July 29, 1999) gives you three exits.[2]

  • You ask at 80%. Once your principal balance reaches 80% of the original value, you can ask your servicer in writing to cancel. The statute requires a good payment history, current payments, proof the home's value hasn't dropped below its original value, and a certification that no junior lien (a second loan against the home) sits on it.[2] [4]
  • It ends itself at 78%. The servicer generally must end PMI when the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the original value, as long as you are current. If you are behind, it ends shortly after you catch up.[2] [3]
  • It ends at the halfway point. PMI must end the month after the midpoint of the amortization schedule, year 15 of a 30-year loan, even if the balance never reached 78%, provided you are current.[2]

“Original value” is the lower of the contract price or the appraised value at purchase.[3] Your home's growth doesn't move the automatic date.

It only helps if your servicer or the loan's investor lets you cancel earlier on a new value, and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac can set their own cancellation guidelines as long as they're no less favorable to you than the law.[2] Ask your servicer what it accepts.

A worked example

PMI on a $400,000 purchase with 5% down

  1. Closing

    $380,000 loan, 95% of original value

    PMI starts. The original value is $400,000, so the 80% line is $320,000 and the 78% line is $312,000.

  2. About year 1080%: you may request

    Balance reaches $320,000

    On a 30-year loan at an assumed 6.5%, the schedule gets here around month 124. Extra principal payments get you here sooner.

  3. About year 1178%: automatic

    Balance reaches $312,000

    The servicer must end PMI at roughly month 135 if you are current. You don't have to ask.

  4. Year 15Final cutoff

    Halfway point of the loan

    Even if the balance somehow stayed above 78%, PMI ends the month after the midpoint if you are current.

Takeaway

Requesting at 80% instead of waiting for 78% saves about a year of premiums in this example, and a lump-sum payment can pull the date forward.

The rates in that timeline are my assumption, so your dates will shift. The thresholds don't. If you come into a lump sum, a mortgage recast is one way to use it, and extra principal payments count toward the 80% line.[2]

Why FHA mortgage insurance is the expensive one

FHA premiums don't follow the HPA. The CFPB says FHA and VA loans have different requirements.[2] The table above shows the FHA rule: 11 years if you put down 10% or more, otherwise the full term.[6]

Urban Institute makes the same point about economics: because PMI cancels at 78% while the FHA annual premium stays for the life of the loan, PMI's advantage grows over time. In Urban's 95% LTV example with PMI canceled after six years, the life-of-loan cost of PMI beat FHA for credit scores of 700 and above.[7]

My view: FHA is a fine on-ramp for someone with a 640 credit score and 3.5% saved. It is a poor long-term arrangement. Plan the exit on day one, which usually means refinancing into a conventional loan once you have about 20% equity.

Compare that against the FHA loan types, and see home equity loan vs refinance and what a cash-out refinance is before you pay refinance costs to dodge a premium.

The deduction is back

Here is a detail most explainers still get wrong. Publication 936 for tax year 2025 says the itemized deduction for mortgage insurance premiums has expired. That changes for 2026: the IRS says the election to deduct qualified mortgage insurance premiums has been made permanent.[8]

The IRS's draft 2026 Publication 936 says qualified mortgage insurance includes premiums from the VA, FHA, the Rural Housing Service, and private insurers, and the deduction is limited if your adjusted gross income exceeds $100,000 ($50,000 if married filing separately).[9]

It is a draft, and you have to itemize, so check the final publication before you count on it. On a $2,123 FHA premium, a deduction doesn't change the decision. It does change the size of the bill by a few hundred dollars for people who itemize.

How I would decide

  • You can reach 20% down without waiting years. Skip mortgage insurance entirely.
  • Your credit score is 740 or higher. Get a PMI quote and an FHA quote side by side. Urban found PMI gave the lower monthly payment at 740 and above when price adjustments were left out, and PMI ends on its own.
  • Your credit score is weak and you have 3.5% down.FHA is probably cheaper today. Write down the refinance date.
  • Prices are rising faster than you can save. Paying PMI for a few years can beat renting while you chase 20%. Compare it with renting vs buying and the rate environment before you assume waiting is free. The 2026 housing reset context is worth a read too.

Takeaway

Mortgage insurance is the price of buying before you have 20%. Pay it if the math says so, but know the date it ends: 78% on a conventional loan, 11 years or never on FHA. For the mechanics underneath, see how a mortgage actually works.

Sources and further reading

  1. 1.PrimaryCFPB, "What is private mortgage insurance?". PMI protects the lender, when it is required, monthly vs upfront premiums, and the rate trade-off.
  2. 2.PrimaryCFPB, "When can I remove private mortgage insurance (PMI) from my loan?". Request at 80%, automatic termination at 78%, final termination at the midpoint, FHA and VA exceptions, investor guidelines.
  3. 3.Primary12 U.S.C. 4901, Homeowners Protection Act definitions. Defines the cancellation date (80% of original value), termination date (78%) and original value.
  4. 4.Primary12 U.S.C. 4902, Termination of private mortgage insurance. Written request, good payment history, no subordinate lien, property value evidence, automatic termination and final termination at the midpoint.
  5. 5.PrimaryFHFA, "Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Private Mortgage Insurer Eligibility Requirements (PMIERs)". The charter requirement for credit enhancement above 80% LTV, and mortgage insurance as the most common form.
  6. 6.PrimaryHUD, Mortgagee Letter 2023-05. FHA annual premium table by loan size, term and LTV, the 11-year versus full-term duration rule, and the 1.75% upfront premium.
  7. 7.DataUrban Institute, "Mortgage Insurance Data at a Glance 2023". PMI vs FHA monthly payment comparison at 96.5% and 95% LTV by credit score, June 23, 2023 rates, and the lifetime-cost comparison.
  8. 8.PrimaryIRS, Publication 505 (2026), "What's New for 2026". The election to deduct qualified mortgage insurance premiums has been made permanent.
  9. 9.PrimaryIRS, draft 2026 Publication 936, "Home Mortgage Interest Deduction". Qualified mortgage insurance definition and the $100,000 adjusted gross income limit ($50,000 married filing separately). Draft.

Frequently asked questions

What is mortgage insurance?
Mortgage insurance is a policy that pays your lender if you stop making mortgage payments. It protects the lender, not you, and you can still lose your home to foreclosure if you fall behind. Lenders usually require it when you put down less than 20% on a conventional loan, and FHA loans carry their own version for almost every borrower.
What is the difference between PMI and MIP?
PMI is private mortgage insurance on a conventional loan, sold by private insurers through your lender, and MIP is the mortgage insurance premium on an FHA loan, charged by the government. PMI price depends on your credit score and down payment and can be canceled at 80% or 78% of the original value. FHA MIP is a flat 1.75% upfront plus 0.55% a year at 3.5% down, and it usually lasts the life of the loan.
How do you get rid of PMI?
You can ask your servicer in writing to cancel PMI once your balance reaches 80% of the original value, and it must end automatically at 78% if you are current. You need a good payment history, no junior liens, and proof the home has not lost value. PMI must also end the month after the halfway point of the loan, which is year 15 of a 30-year mortgage, if you are current.
Does FHA mortgage insurance ever go away?
Yes, but only in two cases. If you put down 10% or more on a 30-year loan of $726,200 or less, the annual premium ends after 11 years. Otherwise it lasts for the full loan term, so the usual exit is refinancing into a conventional loan once you have about 20% equity.
How much does mortgage insurance cost?
FHA charges 1.75% of the loan upfront plus 0.55% a year at 3.5% down, which is about $177 a month on a $386,000 loan. Private PMI on a 3.5%-down conventional loan ran from 0.46% to 1.50% of the loan a year in 2023, depending on credit score, or roughly $148 to $483 a month on the same loan. Higher credit scores and larger down payments push PMI toward the low end.
Is mortgage insurance tax deductible?
Starting in 2026, yes, if you itemize. The IRS says the election to deduct qualified mortgage insurance premiums has been made permanent, and the deduction is limited if adjusted gross income exceeds $100,000 ($50,000 if married filing separately). It covers premiums tied to a first or second home and includes private, FHA, VA and Rural Housing mortgage insurance.

Written by

Tech Talk News Editorial

Computer engineering background. Writes about software, AI, markets, and real estate, and the places where the three meet.

More about the author
ShareXLinkedInRedditEmail