Home Equity Loan vs Refinance: Keep a Cheap Mortgage and Borrow Separately
With the 30-year mortgage rate at 7.11%, a homeowner holding a 3.5% first mortgage who borrows $50,000 pays about $24,000 less over five years with a home equity loan than with a cash-out refinance. Here is the math, the decision flow, and the tax rule that most borrowers misread.
Key takeaways
- Take a home equity loan if your first mortgage rate is below today’s rate, and take a cash-out refinance only if your mortgage rate is above it; Freddie Mac put the 30-year fixed average at 7.11% on November 12, 2026.
- On a $250,000 balance at 3.5% with $50,000 of cash needed, a home equity loan at 8.5% costs $1,744 a month and a cash-out refinance at 7.11% costs $2,018, which is about $24,000 more over five years once closing costs are counted.
- If your mortgage rate is 8.25%, the same $50,000 cash-out refinance saves about $384 a month and repays about $7,500 of extra closing cost in roughly 20 months.
- Home equity loan interest is deductible only when the money buys, builds or substantially improves the home that secures the loan, and only if you itemize; the 2026 standard deduction is $16,100 single and $32,200 married filing jointly.
- Cash-out refinance closing costs run about 2% to 5% of the new loan, so $9,000 on $300,000 at 3%, while a home equity loan commonly costs a few hundred to a few thousand dollars and some lenders pay it.
Keep your first mortgage and borrow with a home equity loan, unless your mortgage rate is higher than today's market rate.
Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% on November 12, 2026, so for anyone holding a 3% or 4% mortgage, a cash-out refinance means trading a cheap rate for an expensive one.[1]
A home equity loan is a second mortgage: a lump sum, a fixed rate, and a second monthly payment, with your first mortgage left alone. A cash-out refinance is a new, larger first mortgage that pays off the old one and hands you the difference in cash.
I ran both on the same house below, and the gap is bigger than most comparison pages admit. The decision isn't which product has the lower rate. It's what happens to the mortgage you already have, because only one of these two products makes you give it up.
Summary
The two products side by side
Both lend against your equity, which is your home's value minus what you still owe. Lenders set a cap on total borrowing as a share of value, commonly around 80% to 85% for both products, so confirm the number on your quote. For a deeper look at the refinance side, see what a cash-out refinance is.
| Feature | Home equity loan | Cash-out refinance |
|---|---|---|
| Your first mortgage | Stays as is, rate and term untouched | Paid off and replaced at today's rate |
| What you get | A lump sum, fixed rate, second payment | Cash at closing, one larger payment |
| Rate applies to | Only the new money | Your entire balance |
| Closing costs | A few hundred to a few thousand dollars[4] | About 2% to 5% of the new loan[5] |
| Typical term | 5 to 30 years | Usually a new 30-year clock |
| Tax rule on the interest | Buy, build or improve the home only | Same, on the cash-out portion |
Sources: Credible and Bankrate for closing costs; IRS Publication 936 for the tax rule.
Start with the rate on the mortgage you already have
Everything below turns on one comparison: your first mortgage rate against what a new first mortgage costs today. Check your statement, then check the current average. Here is the flow I use.
Decision flow
Your current mortgage rate picks the product.
What you check
- Your first mortgage rateOn your statement
- Today’s 30-year rate7.11% on Nov. 12, 2026
- Cash you needAnd your home’s equity
Is your rate below today’s rate?
The gap decides it
What to do
- Below market: home equity loanKeep the cheap rate, borrow separately
- Above market: cash-out refinanceLower the whole balance and take cash
- Within half a point: price bothUse the break-even formula below
Decision rule used throughout this article. Market rate: Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, November 12, 2026.
Takeaway
Compare the rate on your existing mortgage with today's rate before you compare any two loan quotes. If yours is lower, a refinance has to beat a rate you can never get back.
A worked example: the 3.5% mortgage
Take a $500,000 house with a $250,000 first mortgage at 3.5% and 25 years left. You need $50,000. A home equity loan at 8.5% over 15 years is my assumption, because lenders price these above first-mortgage rates.
A cash-out refinance takes a new $300,000, 30-year loan at 7.11%, which flatters the refinance, since cash-out loans usually price higher than the survey average. Closing costs are $1,500 for the equity loan and 3% of $300,000, or $9,000, for the refinance.
Keep mortgage, add equity loan
Cash-out refinance
- Closing costs$1,500$9,000
- Total monthly payment$1,744$2,018
- Interest paid in the first five years$60,149$103,811
- Debt still owed after five years$255,513$282,724
The refinance costs $274 more every month, $43,662 more in interest over five years, $7,500 more to close, and still leaves you owing $27,211 more at the end.
Add the payments and closing costs and the five-year cash outlay is $106,136 for the equity loan against $130,087 for the refinance, a gap of $23,951, or about $24,000. The blended rate on the keep path is 4.33%, since $250,000 at 3.5% and $50,000 at 8.5% average out low. The refinance rate is 7.11%.
Takeaway
The equity loan's 8.5% looks worse than the refinance's 7.11% on a rate sheet. It applies to $50,000. The refinance rate applies to $300,000. That's why headline rates mislead here.
When the refinance wins: the 8.25% mortgage
Now flip it. Same house, same $50,000, but your $250,000 mortgage carries 8.25% with 28 years left, which is what an adjustable-rate loan can look like after a reset. Keeping it and adding the same $50,000 equity loan costs $1,910 plus $492, or $2,402 a month. The cash-out refinance at 7.11% costs $2,018.
That saves $384 a month. The refinance costs $7,500 more to close than the equity loan, and $7,500 divided by $384 is about 20 months to break even. After that you pocket the difference.
Be honest about the catch: the new loan restarts a 30-year clock, so part of the saving is a longer term, not a lower price. If you plan to sell within two years, the break-even never arrives.
The break-even formula is the one test I trust. Divide the extra closing cost of the refinance by the monthly payment it saves. Under three years is almost always worth doing. Over five, skip it. In between, it depends on how long you'll stay in the house.
The blended-rate trap when you need a lot of cash
Size changes the answer. Suppose only $60,000 remains on a 3% mortgage and you need $200,000. An equity loan at 8.5% on that much money blends to (60,000 × 3% + 200,000 × 8.5%) ÷ 260,000, or about 7.23%.
A cash-out refinance at 7.11% would be 0.12 points cheaper on $260,000, or roughly $312 a year, against about $7,800 in closing costs. That's a 25-year break-even, so the equity loan still wins on this example.
I didn't expect the cheap-rate advantage to survive a $200,000 borrow, but it does, on these assumptions. Run the blend before you assume the cheap rate has to be defended.
Two limits apply to refinancing. Fannie Mae's guide requires an existing first mortgage to be at least 12 months old, and the borrower to have been on title at least six months, before a cash-out refinance closes.[6]
And rates move with bond markets, not just the Fed, which explains why mortgage rates don't track the Fed.
The tax rule, and why the deduction is often worth $0
Interest on either product is deductible only if the money is used to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures the loan.[2] IRS Publication 936 says a refinance counts as home acquisition debt only up to the old mortgage balance, and cash beyond that qualifies only if it goes into the house.[3]
The 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act suspended the broader deduction for 2018 through 2025. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act made the suspension permanent in July 2025, according to Journal of Accountancy and Tax Adviser coverage of the law.[7]
The second condition is the one people miss: you have to itemize. The 2026 standard deduction is $16,100 for single filers and $32,200 for married couples filing jointly.[8] In the 3.5% example, the first-year interest on the $50,000 equity loan is about $4,184 and on the $250,000 first mortgage about $8,648.
That's $12,832 combined, below even the single standard deduction. At the 22% bracket the deduction would be worth about $920 if you could use it. Most people in this position can't.
If the money pays off credit cards, buys a car or funds a renovation on a different property, the interest isn't deductible at all. Price the loan at its after-tax cost, which for most households is the full rate.
What the money is for matters more than the product
- Renovation of this house. The cleanest use. It can add value and keeps the interest deductible for those who itemize.
- Credit card payoff. Swapping double-digit credit card rates for 8.5% saves real money, but it turns unsecured debt into a lien on your home. Missing payments now risks foreclosure instead of collection calls. I'm wary of this one unless the cards stay paid off afterward.
- Tuition. Usually a mistake. Federal student loans carry income-driven repayment and other protections that a home loan doesn't.
- Investment property or a business. The deduction follows where the money went, not what secures the loan, so keep clean records. And remember the house is the collateral if the venture fails.
Both products put your home at risk if you can't pay. A home equity loan adds a second lien and a second payment. A refinance puts one bigger loan on the house. Neither is a safe place to park risk you can't afford.
What I'd do
If my first mortgage sat at 3.5% and the market was at 7.11%, I'd borrow what I needed through a home equity loan and keep the first mortgage untouched. I'd get three quotes, ask each lender whether it pays the closing costs, and compare the all-in monthly payment, not the rate.
If my mortgage were above 7.5%, I'd run the break-even on a refinance. Nobody should refinance a sub-4% mortgage to pay for a kitchen, and the numbers above show why.
If you are still deciding whether to refinance without taking cash, or want the mechanics of how your payment splits between interest and principal, how a mortgage actually works covers it. It starts where this article stops.
Sources and further reading
Sources this article names, linked so you can check them.
- 1.DataFreddie Mac, "Primary Mortgage Market Survey". 30-year fixed average of 7.11% and 15-year of 6.45% on November 12, 2026; the 30-year was 6.24% a year earlier.
- 2.PrimaryInternal Revenue Service, "Interest on Home Equity Loans Often Still Deductible Under New Law". Interest is deductible only when the borrowed money buys, builds or substantially improves the home securing the loan; paying off credit cards or student loans does not qualify.
- 3.PrimaryIRS Publication 936, "Home Mortgage Interest Deduction". Refinanced debt counts as acquisition debt only up to the old balance; additional debt not used to buy, build or improve the home does not qualify.
- 4.ReportingCredible, "HELOC closing costs". Home equity closing costs range from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, and some lenders cover them.
- 5.ReportingBankrate, "How much it costs to refinance". Refinance closing costs generally run 2% to 5% of the new loan balance.
- 6.PrimaryFannie Mae Selling Guide, "Cash-out refinance transactions". A borrower must have been on title six months, and the existing first mortgage must be at least 12 months old.
- 7.ReportingThe Tax Adviser, "Details of tax changes in Senate reconciliation bill". The act makes permanent the $750,000 cap and the exclusion of home-equity interest from qualified residence interest.
- 8.PrimaryInternal Revenue Service, "Tax inflation adjustments for tax year 2026". 2026 standard deduction of $16,100 for single filers and $32,200 for married filing jointly; 22% bracket starts at $50,400 single.
Frequently asked questions
- Is it better to get a home equity loan or refinance?
- A home equity loan is better when your current mortgage rate is below today’s market rate, and a cash-out refinance is better when your mortgage rate is above it. The 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.11% on November 12, 2026, so most homeowners with a 3% to 4% mortgage should keep it and borrow against the equity separately. If the two rates are close, compare the full quotes using the break-even formula in this article.
- Is a home equity loan cheaper than a cash-out refinance?
- Usually yes in upfront cost and often yes in total cost. Closing costs on a home equity loan run from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, and some lenders pay them, while a cash-out refinance runs about 2% to 5% of the whole new loan, or $9,000 on a $300,000 balance at 3%. The refinance also resets the rate on your entire balance, which is only a good deal when that rate is lower than the one you have.
- Is home equity loan interest tax deductible in 2026?
- Only if you use the money to buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures the loan, and only if you itemize deductions. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act made that limit permanent in July 2025. Because the 2026 standard deduction is $16,100 for single filers and $32,200 for married couples filing jointly, many borrowers who qualify still get no deduction in practice.
- Does a cash-out refinance or a home equity loan hurt my first mortgage?
- A home equity loan leaves your first mortgage exactly as it is and adds a second lien and a second payment. A cash-out refinance does the opposite: it pays off your first mortgage and replaces it with a larger one at today’s rate. If your first mortgage is 3.5% and the market is 7.11%, the refinance is what hurts, because it swaps your cheap rate for an expensive one.
- When does a cash-out refinance win?
- A cash-out refinance wins when your current mortgage rate is above the market rate. On a $250,000 mortgage at 8.25%, taking $50,000 of cash through a refinance at 7.11% cuts the combined monthly payment from $2,402 to $2,018, a saving of $384 a month, and the extra closing cost pays back in about 20 months. The refinance also wins when you need a large sum, because the blended rate on a big equity loan climbs quickly.
Written by
Tech Talk News Editorial
Computer engineering background. Writes about software, AI, markets, and real estate, and the places where the three meet.
More about the author