Bull vs Bear: The 20% Rule, and Why Bears End Sooner Than You Fear

A bear market is a 20% fall from a recent high and a bull market is a 20% rise from a low. The S&P 500 data says the average bear lasts 289 days and the average bull 988, and the worst bear on record contained a 46.8% rally.

Tech Talk News Editorial7 min readUpdated Nov 18, 2026
#bull market#bear market#market cycles#investing basics
ShareXLinkedInRedditEmail
Bull vs Bear: The 20% Rule, and Why Bears End Sooner Than You Fear

Key takeaways

  • A bear market is a fall of at least 20% from a recent high, measured on closing prices, and a bull market is a rise of at least 20% from a prior low. A fall of 10% to 20% is a correction.
  • Since 1928, the S&P 500 has had 27 bear markets, averaging a 35% loss over 289 days, while the average bull market gained 112% over 988 days, or 2.7 years (Ned Davis Research, through March 2025).
  • Averages hide the spread: in Yardeni Research data the median bull market lasted 633 days and the median bear 261, because a few giants like the 4,494-day, 582% bull of 1987 to 2000 pull the bull average up.
  • The S&P 500 spent about 78% of the days between June 1928 and October 2022 in a bull market, by summing Yardeni Research's tables, so a bear market is the exception and not the default.
  • The worst bear on record had a bull market inside it: the S&P 500 fell 44.7% from September 1929 to November 1929, rallied 46.8% to April 1930, then lost another 83.0% by June 1932.

A bear market is a fall of at least 20% from a recent high, measured on closing prices. A bull market is a rise of at least 20% from a prior low. A fall of 10% to 20% is a correction, and anything smaller is a pullback.

That is the whole definition, and almost no news anchor says it out loud. The more useful facts come after it: the average S&P 500 bear market since 1928 lasted 289 days, the average bull lasted 988, and the worst crash on record had a 46.8% rally buried inside it.[1]

27
20% rule
S&P 500 bear markets since 1928
-35%
289 days
Average bear loss
+112%
988 days
Average bull gain
33 days
Feb to Mar 2020
Shortest bear on record

Summary

Bull means prices are rising and investors are confident. Bear means prices are falling and they are not. The S&P 500 (an index of 500 large US companies, the usual yardstick for the market) is the benchmark nearly everyone means when they say “the market is in a bear.”

Four labels, one ruler

The names are a ladder. Each rung is a fall from a recent peak, and the rung you are on depends only on how far down the closing price has gone. Nobody certifies it, and no committee votes.

LabelMove from a recent high or lowHow it is measured
PullbackDown less than 10%From the most recent high
CorrectionDown 10% to 20%From the most recent high
Bear marketDown 20% or moreClosing price versus the most recent closing high[1]
Bull marketUp 20% or moreFrom the low that ended the last bear

The 20% line is a convention. A 19.8% drop and a 20.1% drop feel identical from the inside, and only one of them gets the headline. Don't put magic weight on it.

It works as a filter, because pullbacks of 5% or 10% happen all the time and rarely mean anything, while a 20% fall usually means something structural broke.

The average bear is shorter than the average bull, and the average hides the spread

Hartford Funds, using Ned Davis Research data through March 2025, counts 27 S&P 500 bear markets since 1928. They lost 35% on average and lasted 289 days, about 9.6 months. The average bull market gained 112% over 988 days, or 2.7 years.[1]

Average bear market

Average bull market

  1. Length (days)
    289
    988
  2. Size of the move (percent)
    -35%
    +112%
Source: Hartford Funds, using Ned Davis Research data on S&P 500 bull and bear markets since 1928, through March 31, 2025. Bear markets use a 20% decline on closing prices.

Yardeni Research publishes every episode, and I added the table up myself. Through October 2022 it lists 22 bear markets averaging a 36.6% loss over 341 days, and 24 bull markets averaging a 121% gain over 1,101 days.[2]

Different counting rules give different averages, which is why you will see three or four numbers quoted for the same thing. The shape is the same in every version. Bulls are longer and bigger than bears.

The medians are more honest than the averages. The median bear in Yardeni's table lasted 261 days and the median bull 633, about 1.7 years.

A few giants drag the bull average up, like the 4,494-day, 582% climb from December 1987 to March 2000.[2] If someone tells you bull markets last about three years, the correct reply is that some last three months and one lasted twelve years.

Add up the days and the market spends about 78% of its time in a bull. Between the June 1928 trough and the October 2022 trough, Yardeni's bulls total 26,436 days and the bears 7,511.[2] Bear markets are interruptions. That is the fact I wish somebody had told me before my first bear market.

Takeaway

The default state of the S&P 500 is rising. A bear market costs 35% on average, takes about 9.6 months, and has been followed by a new bull market every time since 1928.

The last four bears ran from 33 days to 929 days, and every one ended

Recent history makes the range concrete. The four most recent bear markets in Yardeni's table lost between 25.4% and 56.8%, and they ran from 33 days to 929.[2] Each one was followed by a bull market that more than made up the loss.

Four most recent S&P 500 bear markets, through October 2022

From 33 days to 929 days, and every one ended

  1. Mar 2000 to Oct 2002-49.1%

    Dot-com bust

    The index fell from 1,527.46 to 776.76 over 929 days. The bull before it ran 4,494 days. The bull after it, October 2002 to October 2007, gained 101.5%.

  2. Oct 2007 to Mar 2009-56.8%

    Global financial crisis

    The index fell from 1,565.15 to 676.53 over 517 days, the deepest bear since the Depression in this table. The bull that began at the March 9, 2009 low gained 400.5% over 3,999 days.

  3. Feb 19 to Mar 23, 2020-33.9%

    Pandemic crash

    The index fell from 3,386.15 to 2,237.40 in 33 days, the shortest bear on record. The bull that followed gained 114.4% in 651 days.

  4. Jan 3 to Oct 12, 2022-25.4%

    Inflation and rate-hike bear

    The index fell from 4,796.56 to 3,577.03 over 282 days, a shallow bear by the numbers. It ended at the October 12, 2022 low.

Takeaway

Depth and length are not related. A 33.9% drop took 33 days, a 25.4% drop took 282, and a 49.1% drop took 929. You can't guess how long you will be in one from how deep it looks.

Because depth and speed vary this much, the label tells you little about the ride. What you are actually being paid to tolerate is the swing, and what volatility actually means explains how to measure it.

The worst bear on record had a bull market inside it

This is the part the usual explainers skip. By the 20% rule, the 1929 crash contains a bull market. The S&P 500 fell 44.7% from September 7 to November 13, 1929, in 67 days. Then it rose 46.8% to April 10, 1930. Then it lost another 83.0% over 783 days, ending June 1, 1932.[2]

From the September 1929 peak (31.92) to the June 1932 trough (4.40), that is a drop of 86.2%. Anyone who bought near the top of that 46.8% rally still had the 83.0% fall ahead of them.

Black Tuesday and the days around it were the first leg, and the full story is in Black Tuesday 1929. Whether a bear that deep is a recession or something worse is its own question, and recession vs depression draws that line.

I find this the most useful warning in market history. A relief rally of 46.8% looks like a bottom to everyone watching, and it wasn't one. The label is a rear-view mirror.

You only know which one you are in afterward

Both definitions measure from an extreme that gets confirmed later. A bear market is declared 20% below the high, which only counts as the high if the index never exceeds it.

A bull is declared 20% above a low, which counts as the low only if the index never falls below it. Yardeni's table does it after the fact, assigning each peak and trough only once the next 20% move is complete.[2]

So “are we in a bull or a bear?” is the wrong question to ask in real time. The better one is whether you can still add money and sleep if the index drops 35%, which is what the average bear takes.

If you can't, the fix is the mix of what you own, not a forecast, and what diversification actually does covers the mechanics. The seasonal angle gets its own treatment in the October effect, and Black Monday 1987 shows a 33.5% bear market packed into 101 days.[2]

If you hold index funds, the practical version is short. Pick the share of your money that has to be safe for the next five years, keep that out of stocks, and leave the rest alone through the labels.

ETF vs index fund covers the vehicle. The people I know who built real money did it by being indifferent to the headline, and they bought most of their shares at bear-market prices.

Where the words come from

The bear has the better paper trail. In the early 1700s, speculators sold stock they did not yet own, betting the price would fall before delivery.

That was called selling the bearskin, after the proverb about not selling the bearskin before you have caught the bear, and linguist Ben Zimmer says the bear half of the pair is fairly well understood.[3]

The bull is, in Zimmer's word, mysterious.[3] The tidy story that a bull thrusts its horns up and a bear swipes its paws down is repeated everywhere. It has no evidence behind it, and an earlier version of this article repeated it too, so I'm taking it out. Corrected, then.

Sources and further reading

  1. 1.DataHartford Funds, "Bear markets" (Ned Davis Research data through March 31, 2025). 27 S&P 500 bear markets since 1928, 35.24% average decline, 289 days average length, 112% average bull gain over 988 days, and the 20%-on-closing-price definition.
  2. 2.DataYardeni Research, "Stock Market Historical Tables: Bull & Bear Markets" (October 28, 2022). S&P 500 bull and bear market tables since 1928 from Standard & Poor's and Haver Analytics. Averages, medians and the 78% share are the author's arithmetic on those tables.
  3. 3.ReportingMarketplace, "Bears, bulls and BS" (interview with linguist Ben Zimmer). March 4, 2014. The bearskin origin of "bear" and why the origin of "bull" is uncertain.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a bull market and a bear market?
A bull market is a sustained rise of at least 20% from a prior low, and a bear market is a fall of at least 20% from a recent high, measured on closing prices. A fall of 10% to 20% is called a correction. Bull means rising prices and optimism, and bear means falling prices and fear.
How long do bear markets and bull markets last?
The average S&P 500 bear market since 1928 lasted 289 days and lost 35%, while the average bull market lasted 988 days, or 2.7 years, and gained 112%, according to Ned Davis Research data published by Hartford Funds through March 2025. The median is shorter for both, because a handful of long bulls skew the average. The shortest bear on record was 33 days, in February and March 2020.
Why are they called bull and bear markets?
Nobody knows for certain. The bear is better documented: in the early 1700s, speculators sold stock they did not yet own, which was called selling the bearskin after the proverb about not selling the bearskin before you have caught the bear. The bull is more mysterious. The popular story that a bull thrusts its horns up and a bear swipes its paws down is repeated often and has no good evidence behind it.
Is a 10% drop a bear market?
No. A 10% drop is a correction, and a bear market needs a fall of at least 20% from a recent high on closing prices. A decline of less than 10% is a pullback. The labels are a convention, and a 19.8% drop feels the same from the inside as a 20.1% drop even though only the second gets called a bear.
Should you sell in a bear market?
Selling after the fall has started usually locks in the loss, because bear markets have ended in bull markets every time in the S&P 500 record back to 1928. The 2020 bear market fell 33.9% in 33 days and the next bull market gained 114.4% in the 651 days that followed. Whether to hold depends on when you need the money, not on the label.
Does a bear market mean a recession is coming?
Not always. A bear market is a price signal and a recession is a statement about the economy, and the two overlap without matching exactly. The 1929 crash was followed by the Great Depression, but a bear market can also be as short as 33 days, as in 2020. The yield curve and unemployment data are better recession tests than the 20% rule.

Written by

Tech Talk News Editorial

Computer engineering background. Writes about software, AI, markets, and real estate, and the places where the three meet.

More about the author
ShareXLinkedInRedditEmail