Black Tuesday 1929: Not the Worst Day, and the Depression Had Already Begun
On October 29, 1929 the Dow fell 11.73% on a record 16,410,030 shares. Monday was worse, the Federal Reserve dates the Depression to August 1929, and the real damage ran 33 months to a bottom 89% below the peak.
Key takeaways
- On Black Tuesday, October 29, 1929, the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 11.73% to 230.07 on a record 16,410,030 shares traded.
- Black Tuesday was not the worst day of the crash. Black Monday, October 28, fell 12.82%, and the two days together took about 23% off the Dow.
- The Federal Reserve dates the start of the Great Depression to August 1929, two months before Black Tuesday, and says the money supply then fell by nearly 30% from fall 1930 through winter 1933.
- The Dow did not bottom until July 8, 1932, at 41.22, which was 89% below its September 3, 1929 peak of 381.17, and it did not regain that peak until November 23, 1954.
- About 9,100 banks suspended operations from 1930 through 1933, and federal deposit insurance did not start until January 1, 1934, at $2,500 per depositor.
Black Tuesday was October 29, 1929, the day the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 11.73% to 230.07 on a record 16,410,030 shares.[3,4] It is the date everyone remembers, and it isn't the worst day of the 1929 crash. Monday, October 28, was worse, at 12.82%.[4]
It also isn't where the Great Depression started. The Federal Reserve dates that to August 1929, two months earlier.[2] Black Tuesday was the loudest day of a story that took 33 more months to finish, and the Dow bottomed 89% below its peak.[1]
Summary
The setup: a peak, a rate hike, and borrowed money
The Dow closed at 381.17 on September 3, 1929, its peak for the next 25 years.[1] New York's Federal Reserve discount rate (the rate the Fed charges banks to borrow) had reached 6% that August, after the Fed Board had turned down several earlier requests to raise it.[1]
The part that made the crash a crash was credit. By August 1929, brokers were lending small investors more than two-thirds of the face value of the stocks they bought, with more than $8.5 billion out on loan.[4]
The mechanism of margin is the same one that still causes trouble today, and buying on margin explained covers how it works now.
How margin turned a fall into a crash
A price drop wipes out the buyer, and the sale pushes prices down again
What a margin buyer held
- 10% of the price in cashThe buyer's own money
- 90% borrowed from a brokerSecured by the shares themselves
Prices fall
A fall of 10% erases the buyer's entire cash stake.
What happened next
- Broker issues a margin callPut up more cash today
- No cash, shares sold at any priceThe broker protects the loan first
- Selling lowers prices againThe next buyer's stake is now wiped out
Source: author illustration of margin mechanics, using the 10% margin figure from the Federal Reserve History essay on the 1929 crash.
The five days, by the numbers
The week had a rescue attempt, a second panic and a false bottom. The closes below come from the Dow's daily record.
The crash week
October 24 to October 30, 1929
- Thu Oct 24-2.09%
Black Thursday
A record 12,894,650 shares trade.[3] Thomas Lamont of Morgan, Albert Wiggin of Chase and Charles Mitchell of National City meet, and pick Richard Whitney of the Stock Exchange to bid for 25,000 shares of U.S. Steel at $205, well above the market. The visible buying steadies the day.[4]
Takeaway
Black Tuesday was second place in size, and its 16.4 million shares set the volume record. A 12.34% bounce the next day looked like a bottom, with another 33 months of falling still ahead.
I keep coming back to Thursday. A visible rescue, three of the most powerful bankers in the country, a stock exchange official bidding above market for 25,000 shares of one stock. It worked for one session. When it stopped working on Monday, there was no second plan.
The depression began before the crash
The Federal Reserve's history of the Great Depression is blunt: it began in August 1929, when the economic expansion of the Roaring Twenties came to an end.[2] The crash came two months later. It lists the stock market crash as one of several crises that punctuated the contraction, not the thing that started it.[2]
So the standard story has the order wrong. The crash did not push a healthy economy off a cliff. It landed on an economy already turning down. That is also the cleanest way to see how a recession and a depression differ, which recession vs depression works through with the numbers.
What turned a crash into the Depression
The harm that followed was mostly money and banking. The Fed says the money supply fell by nearly 30% from the fall of 1930 through the winter of 1933, and calls its failure to stop that decline its most serious sin of omission.[2]
The banking system supplied the rest. About 1,350 banks suspended operations in 1930, about 2,300 in 1931, about 1,450 in 1932 and about 4,000 in 1933, or about 9,100 in four years.[5]
Trade made it worse, though historians argue about how much. Herbert Hoover signed the Smoot-Hawley tariff on June 17, 1930, ignoring a petition from a thousand economists, and foreign governments responded with tariffs of their own that froze international trade.[6]
The State Department's historians say scholars disagree about how much protection the tariff gave and whether it caused a wave of foreign retaliation.[7]
After the crash week
From the 1929 peak to the 1954 recovery
- Jun 17, 1930
Smoot-Hawley signed
Hoover signs the tariff over the objections of a thousand economists.[6]
- Jan 1, 1934$2,500 covered
Deposit insurance starts
The FDIC begins insuring deposits, after about 4,000 more banks suspended in 1933.[5]
- Nov 23, 1954
The recovery
The Dow finally regains its 1929 high, more than 25 years after the peak.[1]
Takeaway
The crash week took close to half of the Dow. The next 33 months took most of the rest, which is why July 1932 and not October 1929 is the date that tells you how bad it was.
The same pattern shows up in S&P 500 data. By the 20% rule, the first leg down in 1929 was followed by a 46.8% rally and then another 83.0% fall.[10] Bull vs bear market has the table and explains why a relief rally is the most dangerous thing in a bear.
What the 1930s built, and what has changed since
Most of the modern financial rulebook was written in four years. The Banking Act of 1933, known as Glass-Steagall, separated commercial banking from investment banking and created the FDIC.[8] The Securities Act of 1933 required investors to get real financial information about securities for sale, and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 created the Securities and Exchange Commission.[9]
Not all of it lasted. The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999 repealed the provisions of the 1933 law that restricted ties between banks and securities firms.[8] The deposit insurance side did last, and the limit has since been raised from $2,500 to $250,000.[8]
Takeaway
Black Tuesday was the loudest day of a crash that landed on an economy already shrinking. What made it a depression was a money supply that fell by nearly 30% and 9,100 bank suspensions in four years, and the rules that came after were written to stop those two things.
The lesson is leverage, not timing
The lesson I take from 1929 has nothing to do with timing the market. An investor who paid in full could lose money but could not be forced to sell. The people who were wiped out were the ones who held stocks with borrowed money, because they could be made to sell at the worst price on the worst day.
The same structural risk turned up again in Black Monday 1987, and it had run before in the Panic of 1907, which ran the same script before most of these institutions existed. The asset doesn't kill you. The leverage attached to it does.
Sources and further reading
- 1.PrimaryFederal Reserve History, "Stock Market Crash of 1929". Dow peak 381.17 on September 3, 1929, low 41.22 on July 8, 1932 (89% below the peak), recovery on November 23, 1954, the Oct 28 and Oct 29 falls, 10% margin, and the 6% discount rate in August 1929.
- 2.PrimaryFederal Reserve History, "The Great Depression". The Depression began in August 1929, and the money supply fell by nearly 30% from fall 1930 through winter 1933.
- 3.ReportingHistory.com, "1929 stock market crash". Volume figures: 12,894,650 shares on October 24 and 16,410,030 on October 29, and the Dow low of 41.22, 89% below its peak.
- 4.ReportingWikipedia, "Wall Street Crash of 1929". Daily Dow changes for October 24, 28, 29 and 30, the bankers' meeting and Richard Whitney's U.S. Steel bid, and brokers' loans of more than $8.5 billion by August 1929. Cross-checked against the Federal Reserve essay for the Oct 28 and 29 falls.
- 5.PrimaryFDIC, "1930-1939". Bank suspensions of about 1,350 in 1930, 2,300 in 1931, 1,450 in 1932 and 4,000 in 1933, and the start of FDIC insurance on January 1, 1934 at $2,500.
- 6.PrimaryU.S. Senate, "The Senate Passes the Smoot-Hawley Tariff". Hoover signed on June 17, 1930, a thousand economists petitioned for a veto, and foreign tariffs in response froze international trade.
- 7.PrimaryOffice of the Historian, U.S. Department of State, "The Great Depression and U.S. Protectionism". Scholars disagree about the protection the tariff provided and about whether it provoked foreign retaliation.
- 8.PrimaryFederal Reserve History, "Banking Act of 1933 (Glass-Steagall)". Separation of commercial and investment banking, creation of the FDIC, the $2,500 starting limit now $250,000, and repeal of the affiliation limits by Gramm-Leach-Bliley in 1999.
- 9.PrimaryU.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, "The Laws That Govern the Securities Industry". The Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, which created the SEC.
- 10.DataYardeni Research, "Stock Market Historical Tables: Bull & Bear Markets" (October 28, 2022). S&P 500 bear and bull market tables: the 44.7% fall to November 13, 1929, the 46.8% rally to April 10, 1930, and the 83.0% fall to June 1, 1932.
Frequently asked questions
- What happened on Black Tuesday, October 29, 1929?
- The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 11.73% to 230.07 on a record 16,410,030 shares traded on the New York Stock Exchange. It followed a 12.82% fall the day before, so Monday and Tuesday together took about 23% off the index. The trigger was forced selling by leveraged investors: buyers had put up roughly 10% of a stock's price and borrowed the rest, so falling prices wiped out their stakes and triggered margin calls.
- Was Black Tuesday the worst day of the 1929 crash?
- No. Black Monday, October 28, was worse, with the Dow down 12.82% against 11.73% on Black Tuesday. Black Tuesday is the one remembered because it set the volume record at 16,410,030 shares, after a second day of panic. The Dow then rallied 12.34% on October 30, which looked like a bottom and was not.
- Did the 1929 stock market crash cause the Great Depression?
- Not by itself. The Federal Reserve dates the start of the Great Depression to August 1929, when the 1920s expansion ended, two months before the crash. What turned it into the worst depression of the century was the banking collapse and a money supply that fell by nearly 30% from fall 1930 through winter 1933, plus a tariff war. The crash was a symptom and an accelerant.
- What was buying on margin in 1929?
- Buying on margin meant paying about 10% of a stock's price and borrowing the rest from a broker. By August 1929, brokers had more than $8.5 billion out on loan. When prices fell, brokers demanded more cash through margin calls, and if the buyer could not pay, the shares were sold into the falling market. That forced selling is what turned a decline into a crash.
- How far did the stock market fall after 1929, and when did it recover?
- The Dow fell 89% from its September 3, 1929 close of 381.17 to a low of 41.22 on July 8, 1932. It did not regain the 1929 high until November 23, 1954, more than 25 years later. The crash itself took close to half the Dow by mid-November 1929. The longer grind took the rest.
- What changed after the crash to prevent another one?
- The Banking Act of 1933, known as Glass-Steagall, separated commercial from investment banking, and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 created the Securities and Exchange Commission. The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation began insuring deposits on January 1, 1934, up to $2,500 per depositor. Congress repealed the Glass-Steagall banking separation in 1999 through the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act.
Written by
Tech Talk News Editorial
Computer engineering background. Writes about software, AI, markets, and real estate, and the places where the three meet.
More about the author